A day for the victims – judge sends Yates to prison for 408 years
“How can you take my mother and bury her in your yard? And your family walk around my mother for two and a half years?” – Wendy Engeldinger to admitted serial killer Robert Lee Yates Jr.
From The Spokesman-Review newspaper (Spokane, Wash.)
Friday, October 27, 2000
By Kevin Blocker
Staff writer
They attacked with the only weapons they had: words.
Reckless, unfeeling, useless garbage. Sociopath, monster, animal.
One by one, 18 relatives of Robert Lee Yates Jr.’s victims stood up Thursday in a crowded courtroom to talk about their loved ones and their loss.
“Mr. Yates, you deserve to die now,” said Dan Oliver, whose brother, Patrick, was killed by Yates in 1975.
In a brief statement, Yates apologized to the family members.
“Nothing I can say will erase the sorrow, the pain and the anguish that you feel, that I have caused in your lives,” Yates said in his first public comments since his arrest in April. “I pray that God will right the wrongs I’ve committed.”
Superior Court Judge Richard Schroeder sentenced Yates to spend 408 years in prison and pay $620,000 in restitution for murders dating to 1975. He will now face two murder charges in Pierce County. It may be harder to reach a plea agreement there than it was in his home county.
The sentencing brought to a close a plea bargain that saw Yates plead guilty to 13 killings over 25 years, including a string of 10 women with ties to drugs and prostitution in Spokane from 1996 to 1998.
The killings led to a community outcry and the formation of a special task force, which is still investigating him for other unsolved murders.
Yates also pleaded guilty to trying to kill Christine Smith and admits murdering Shawn McClenahan.
Spokane County Prosecutor Steve Tucker did not charge Yates with McClenahan’s death. If Yates decides to appeal his plea, Tucker will file that murder charge against Yates and pursue the death penalty.
Tucker didn’t believe the aggravating circumstances – common scheme or plan and robbery – could have held up on an appeal if he had pursued the death penalty against Yates.
Yates is charged with two murders in Pierce County and will be arraigned in Tacoma on Tuesday at 12:30 p.m. before Superior Court Judge John McCarthy, said Gerry Horne, Pierce County’s chief deputy prosecutor.
Pierce County Prosecutor John Ladenburg said he believes the aggravating circumstances necessary to get a death sentence are present in the murders of Connie LaFontaine and Melinda Mercer.
Schroeder released Yates, 48, into Pierce County’s custody and Yates is expected to be transported there before the beginning of next week, Tucker said.
With Yates in court Thursday was Roger Hunko, his Pierce County attorney. Hunko has handled several capital cases during his career.
In March, Hunko helped convicted murderer Mitchell Rupe escape the death penalty in Thurston County. Rupe is serving a life sentence for the 1981 murders of two bank tellers in Tumwater, Wash.
Hunko praised Tucker for reaching a plea bargain with Yates and forgoing the death penalty in Spokane County.
“I think Spokane should be very proud of its prosecutor,” Hunko said. “It’s a just settlement, and he (Tucker) used good judgment. I know the pain and grief of long litigation.”
But such pain and grief may never last as long as that felt by the families and friends of Yates’ victims, as well as his own family.
Countless tears were shed in the courtroom Thursday. And Yates, the man who was responsible for them, will never be able to wipe them away.
Dan Oliver discovered the body of his brother, Patrick Oliver, and friend Susan Savage in July 1975 after Yates gunned them down in Walla Walla at a picnic in a park.
Oliver told Yates he has stigmatized his (Yates’) wife and his five children, and added that Tucker had been “duped” into bypassing the death penalty by Yates’ defense attorney Richard Fasy.
“We moved on, but we never let go – we never let go,” said Chris Oliver, another of Patrick Oliver’s brothers, as he addressed the court during sentencing.
Tucker said he wasn’t surprised to hear Dan Oliver say he believed he’d been duped into making the deal.
“I still think I did the right thing here regardless of what happens there (in Pierce County),” Tucker said.
Shannon Johnson, the daughter-in-law of Shawn Johnson, told Yates his ultimate judgment still awaits him.
“Someday, Mr. Yates, you will have to face the real judgment day,” she said. “And when you do, I hope you get what you deserve.”
Audrey Oster and Ondraya Smith brought Sunny Oster’s cremated remains with them to the podium to address Yates.
“Sunny Gail Oster,” her sister Audrey said. “Don’t you ever forget her name.”
Wendi Engeldinger, one of the daughters of Melody Murfin, asked Yates why he buried her in the yard of his South Hill home.
“How can you take my mother and bury her in your yard? And your family walk around my mother for two and a half years?”
Engeldinger and her sister, Ann Davis, had Murfin’s remains cremated after the sentencing Thursday.
Yates’ oldest daughter, Sasha Yates, also wanted answers from her father when she addressed the court.
“No one deserves to be killed like that, no one,” Sasha Yates said. “I may never find out why, the reason behind this.”
But Sasha Yates told her father she loved him.
“Like the old saying goes, blood is thicker than water. I still love you, Dad, even though you did this,” she said.
Sasha Yates said life has been hell since her father was arrested in April.
Kyle Yates, who at 12 is the youngest of Yates’ five children, still hasn’t talked to his father because he’s afraid of him, Sasha Yates said. Kyle is his only son.
Also in the courtroom was Yates’ wife, Linda Yates, another daughter, Sonja Yates, and his father, Robert Lee Yates Sr. Linda and Sonja Yates did not address the court or talk to the media.
And, as expected, Robert Lee Yates Jr. provided no answers. However, Fasy didn’t rule out the possibility that he might one day.
“I think that if Mr. Ladenburg agrees to forgo the pursuit of the death penalty (in Pierce County), this community and the people in Pierce County will have some much better explanation,” Fasy said.
Sheriff’s Lt. Doug Silver, a member of the Homicide Task Force, doesn’t think Yates is sorry for what he did, despite the fact he apologized to each victim, his own family, Spokane County and the country he once served in the Army.
Silver said Yates is a sociopath and is adapting to a new set of circumstances – that of convicted killer. “I definitely question” his apology, Silver said.
Silver said police are not finished investigating Yates. He’s still considered a suspect in numerous other unsolved killings in Spokane and around the country.
Outside the courtroom, the pain and suffering felt by family members proved to be just as intense as it was in court.
In addition to the Olivers, none of Yates’ victims had waited longer for Thursday than Nancy Page and Barbara Buttice, the sisters of Susan Savage. Patrick Oliver bucked hay bales that summer of 1975, and Savage had just earned a degree from Washington State University in interior design. Savage had taken a job redecorating a Walla Walla condominium. Supplies for the job arrived during her funeral.
“They had all kinds of potential, really ready to go in life,” said Page, watching the sentencing on TV from an adjacent room in the courthouse.
Buttice said her sister’s murder left her protective of her own children.
“They’ve grown up with a mother who is terrified when they’re late,” Buttice said. “This murder created a fear we’d never known before, a fear of the darkness.”
Both sisters said they expected to die not knowing the identity of their sister’s killer.
“This gives us some knowledge of what happened,” Buttice said. “It’s good to know, but it doesn’t close the book for us.”
Staff writers Mike Roarke, Jonathan Martin and Bill Morlin contributed to this report.




